Judicial Independence and Accountability: Withstanding Political Stress

Authors

Leah Wortham, The Catholic University of America, Columbus School of LawFollow

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2019

Abstract

For democracy and the rule of law to function and flourish, important actors in the justice system need sufficient independence from politicians in power to act under rule of law rather than political pressure. The court system must offer a place where government action can be reviewed, challenged, and, when necessary, limited to protect constitutional and legal bounds, safeguard internationally-recognized human rights, and prevent departures from a fair and impartial system of law enforcement and dispute resolution. Courts also should offer a place where government officials can be held accountable. People within and outside a country need faith that court decisions will be made fairly and under law. Because the Council of Europe’s Group of States against Corruption (“GRECO”) deems judicial independence critical to fighting corruption, GRECO makes a detailed analysis of their members’ judicial system part of their member review process. This Article is a case study of the performance of Poland’s mechanisms for judicial independence and accountability since 2015, a time of extreme political stress in that country. Readers will see parallels to comparable historical and current events around the world.

Recommended Citation

Leah Wortham, Judicial Independence and Accountability: Withstanding Political Stress, 42 FORDHAM INT’L L.J. 875 (2019) (with Fryderyk Zoll).